Why this Video Producer Doesn’t Really Like YouTube [OP-ED]

Why this Video Producer Doesn’t Really Like YouTube [OP ED]

As you’ve probably heard, YouTube has been raving about their astronomical six billion hours of video content viewed per month, which yes, is impressive. Although, for the moment, I want you to take a step back and seriously ask yourself: what does 6 billion hours really mean to us, as businesses?  When I read about the vast growth from the company, let's just say I didn’t go running to the platform posting my latest videos.  Why?  Because I am skeptical of who this platform is really for.  Who watches YouTube videos?

Currently, the five most subscribed to channels on YouTube are (stats from VidStatsX):

  • Smosh
  • JennaMarbles
  • RayWilliamjohnson
  • nigahiga
  • RihannaVevo

Taking a look at some YouTube competition, Vimeo’s five most subscribed to channels are:

  • Vimeo Staff Picks: Hand-selected videos from the staff at Vimeo
  • Documentary Film
  • Everything Animated
  • Nice Type
  • Film School-Filmmaking

What do these two lists show?  The most active YouTubers subscribe to TV shows, comedy, and music.  These channels also make up most of the most viewed channels on YouTube.  These results, as a business, are not very promising.  I too go on YouTube to be entertained, but that means my business becomes lost in the mix.  Vimeo, on the other hand, has a more diverse selection of channels.  While music and videos still top the list, there are other popular choices like Everything Animated where businesses can showcase their work.  It’s not that one channel is better than the other, it’s just companies must realize why each one is popular.

What YouTube Doesn’t Offer

It all boils down to the lack of professionalism and valuable opportunity for engagement of people or businesses we actually want to target.  Even individuals and companies that advertise on their video channels are finding it hard to find a monetary value to their efforts, according to Bloomberg Businessweek.  People are not making money, and people are resorting to the platform for entertainment.  So, what can a business expect to gain?

I’m on YouTube, which may come as a surprise to you.  I post my client videos, use appropriate titles for SEO purposes, even link to them on my social media channels.  But, every time I look at my analytics, I have to scroll and scroll and scroll to find YouTube.  My top referral hits? Facebook, Twitter, and Quora. Even though I’m a video producing company, YouTube doesn’t even hit the top 20.

What I Think YouTube Should Offer

When we read the news today, we hear a lot about social media platforms and how they are making the highest ranks for visual professional engagement (does Pinterest ring a bell?). What YouTube truly lacks is a professional-based offering. Even going back to the offerings of Vimeo, its platform has a more apparent interest in actual video-making from their top categories. Imagine if YouTube, the video giant, offered a professional space that can spotlight professionals and help them appropriately target their markets and increase video analytics. This ideal offering could promote valuable engagement, rather than viral gambling.

Visualize a community where suggested videos and comments are professionally targeted, and a platform that promotes the best in video-making. I would love to use this as a video hosting site that promoted community engagement and a little more of that something to drive professionalism to the world of video and video-makers. For now, though YouTube has the big numbers, but the real question is, will the platform ever use it for us, the professionals?

Don't Miss Any Stories!

Get daily online video news, tips and trends via email!

Posted in Youtube Marketing
About Our Contributing Author - Anish Patel
Anish Patel CEO and Head Producer Revolution Productions: Explanatory Video Production Agency.



Please Note: Opinions expressed in this article are those of the contributing author and not necessarily that of

Become a Contributor: Occasionally, we like to offer experts within the online video industry the chance to write a post for ReelSEO. We like it because it offers you readers great content, and it comes directly from those in the field that are working on the technologies to power this online video revolution of sorts ;-) If you are interested in becoming a contributing author, please feel free to let us know. Read our post on becoming a contributor for additional information.

What do you think? ▼
  • http://www.facebook.com/kameko.thomas Kameko Thomas

    I, too see the differentiation between Vimeo and YouTube, with the former being a space for professionals and businesses to highlight their content, and the latter being – for lack of a better description – more of a free-for-all.

    Because of YouTube's brand recognition, that's where my site's channel (asischronicle.com) is located, but I also ask myself what good it does, when the average YouTube viewer is "just not that into us".

    Also, I'm having a hard time finding ways to make our content "fit" within YouTube's particular landscape.

    Interestingly enough, whenever I mention wanting a Vimeo channel, I often hear arguments against it, even as – in terms of programming – Vimeo hosts more of the content I'm attracted to as a digital media entrepreneur.

    Your idea is solid. I just question if YouTube/Google finds the professional audience valuable enough to carve out and promote a legitimate space for their content.

    I appreciate your insight. Thanks!!

  • Sam Simon

    I produce videos for b2b markets and typically I agree completely with these comments. It's very easy to get lost and the return from posting videos to YouTube typically isn't very high. But because of it's absolutely staggering audience it's worth having a presence. My personal opinion though is to spend more time developing those "roads" to your video through other channels like blogs, partner websites and and other sites where your target audience already visit.

    • Revolution Video

      Completely agree, Sam. Using blogs, partner websites, and other relevant sites is such a better traffic-builder than YouTube.

  • http://twitter.com/JoinRevolution Revolution Video

    Kameko, I have teetered over Vimeo and YouTube for years, but when I really thought about it, it became clear to me that YouTube initiatives are not for professionals. I host my videos on Wistia, which gives really great analytics.They don't offer the community such as Youtube and Vimeo, but the platform is designed with the solid programming that you may be looking for.

  • Hurdie Burk

    Nice to have choices for platforms we think bring best results.

  • http://josuemolina.com/ J.Molina

    I think it's getting there. Just need to filter out all the non-sense roaming around in it.

↑ Top